- New Restaurants
- Crave Deals
-
Top Picks
- Bakeries
- Barbecue
- Breweries
- Brunch
- Burgers
- BYOB
- Cafes & Coffee Shops
- Cajun and Creole
- Candy Stores
- Cupcakes
- Dessert
- Doughnuts
- Fall Drinks
- Fall Sweets
- Farmers Markets
- Farm-To-Table
- Fireside Dining
- Gameday Take-Out
- Historic Dining
- Hot Dogs
- Ice Cream
- Irish Pubs
- Mexican Restaurants
- On the Go Dining
- Outdoor Dining
- Pancakes
- Philly Favorites in Montco
- Pizza
- Premium Dining
- Private Dining
- Pumpkin Spice
- Romantic Dining
- Soup
- Sports Bars
- Steakhouses
- Tomato Pie
- Vegetarian
- Winter Drinks
- Eagles Game Day Eats
- Area Guides
- Food Features
- Events
Montco's Best Pizza Tomato Pie
Valley Forge & Montgomery County, PA
There are two things you need to know before reading this list:
1. Pizza and tomato pie are totally different.
2. Montgomery County has the best of both.
Without further ado, here are our top picks for tomato pie.
A post shared by Corropolese Bakery (@corropolesebakery) on
CORROPOLESE BAKERY AND DELI
Norristown
Famous for their tomato pie, this family-owned bakery is the real deal. For no extra charge, Corropolese will even customize your pie with the logo of your favorite Philadelphia area team – perfect for game day.
CHIARO'S PIZZA RESTAURANT
Green Lane
The 2016 and 2017 winners of Montco's Best Pizza Tournament, Chiaro's makes a mean tomato pie too. This Green Lane gem has served Montgomery County for over 40 years and grown to include locations in Pennsburg, Skippack and Sellersville.
BRAVO PIZZA WORCESTER
Worchester
Using traditional Sicilian recipes passed down through generations, Sal Sparacio and his mom are cooking up next-level Italian classics. Their Sicilian tomato pie is no exception – taste the difference for yourself right here in Montco.
WEGMANS FOOD MARKET AND PUB
Multiple Locations
The quality and convenience of Wegmans tomato pie makes it a must-have on your next grocery list. Top it with their fresh herbs and produce for a simple, delicious meal that's fun to make with your family.
CONSHOHOCKEN ITALIAN BAKERY
Conshohocken
Winner of Philly A-List's Best Bakery five years in a row, the Conshocken Italian Bakery is a genuine Conshy classic. Their custom tomato pies with homemade tomato sauce are sure to be a hit.
COLLEGEVILLE ITALIAN BAKERY PIZZERIA NAPOLETANA
Collegeville
Their name is as long as their tomato pie is delicious. At Collegeville Italian Bakery, expect to taste fresh-baked bread and recipes of family tradition from la Campagnia.
CARLINO'S
Ardmore
Boasting Olde World-style specialty foods and Italian hospitality, Carlino's makes its tomato pie with the finest, freshest ingredients. Stop in for a slice, along with their other spectacular gourmet meals to-go.
TONY RONI'S
Conshohocken, Spring House, Willow Grove
Well-known across the Philadelphia region, Tony Roni's tomato pie has a crispy crust that pairs perfectly with their signature tomato sauce. If you're looking for a little crunch in your tomato pie, Tony Roni's has you covered.
TRIOS TOMATO PIE
Glenside
When tomato pie is in the name, you know it's something special. In addition to the traditional favorite, Trios also makes a variety of white tomato pies. Sounds crazy, but it really works.
SAM'S ITALIAN MARKET & BAKERY
Willow Grove
For a thick slice of Italian bakery heaven, look no further than the tomato pie at Sam's Italian Market. For over 50 years, Sam's has been serving up fresh pastas, sausages and other Italian favorites in the Philadelphia area.
